Entry: STAND-UP COMEDY/TV Wednesday, October 15, 2008



I recently saw the new Chris Rock special on HBO, "Kill the Messenger," and  Mr. Rock's stand-up is still very, very strong.  The material was great - not significantly less or more great that his past few specials, but the format of this one was a bit different.  This special took three different performances - one in New York, one in London and one in Johannesburg - and edited them together.   I'm pretty sure it was all the same material on three separate nights, but spliced together.  And this wasn't something that they were trying to hide.  He was wearing different outfits on each night and addressed the specific crowds during certain bits.  Overall, I'm inclined to think this wasn't a wise conceptual move. 

In stand-up comedy a fair amount of effort goes into making the material seem spontaneous.  Although this isn't obviously the case, the delivery shouldn't make the material seem "written."  In reality, a comic can (and should) work on new material in a set also containing old material, or go off on unplanned tangents.  Ideally, the audience shouldn't be able to tell what was unique to that set and what has been on a comics set list for months. 

The format of "Kill the Messenger" works against that.  It reminds the viewer of the mechanics behind tricking an audience into forgetting that the performer says this stuff exactly the same way night after night. 

The expectations that a fan has of a comedian have always amused me.  While most fans understand that comedians don't come up with material on the spot and say things that just come to them onstage, they do tend to feel that if they see you live, the material should be all new the next time you come into town.  It's quite common to overhear people leaving a comedy club with a tone of disappointment in their voice as they say "I heard a couple of those jokes before." 

This is in stark contrast to the world of music where fans exit in rage if the band hasn't played every single one of their greatest hits.  Moreover, many fans only want to hear the hits.  I was recently reading on a message board that at recent concerts of a very popular band, people had brought banners reading "No New Shit."    

 

   29 comments

Herbalincenseguide
May 23, 2013   05:33 AM PDT
 
we are the best herbal incense online wholesaler and we have been dealing in Herbal incense online sale from last 10 years. we can provide you excellent quality of Herbal incense and spice incense. Herbal Incense is legal in all states and you will surely enjoy it.
Viagra generic
July 28, 2012   08:37 AM PDT
 
Such a great post. i really like this.
abercrombie outlet
June 14, 2012   01:28 AM PDT
 
Your site provided us with valuable information to work on|.You have done a marvellous job!by the way to tell you ,your airtical is benifit for mr ,thank you.
Coach Outlet
May 19, 2012   12:56 AM PDT
 
you will have the surprise when you place the order from http://www.gotocoachoutlet.org/! Go head! We ship your order as soon as possible, top convenient for your business. Please feel free to buy them.
Coach Handbags
May 11, 2012   02:08 AM PDT
 
Thanks for sharing this opinion. Regards for you. Good job! Very helpful information This is a cool blogging platform.
Hermes Bags
May 7, 2012   03:42 AM PDT
 
I discovered your web page recently plus started follow your posts.Brilliant , i actually resembling your web publication so much.
Coach Coupons
April 25, 2012   11:19 PM PDT
 
A handful of common sense is worth a bushel of learning.
nike air max skyline
April 24, 2012   10:07 AM PDT
 
Hey ! am I glad to vist your blog ! from this I can get some information and facts that I didní»t know prior to. You made my day. Thank you rather much!,961114,http://tomfranck.blogdrive.com/comments?id=496
Chloe Handbags
April 23, 2012   01:13 AM PDT
 
Never deter till tomorrow that which you can do today.
Chloe Handbags
April 23, 2012   01:13 AM PDT
 
Never deter till tomorrow that which you can do today.
Free Beats By Dre
April 20, 2012   12:41 AM PDT
 
Business may be troublesome,but idleness is pernicious.
Jordan Concord 11
April 18, 2012   02:50 AM PDT
 
.Experience without learning is better than learning without experience.
Jordan Retro 3
April 17, 2012   02:11 AM PDT
 
Idleness is the key of beggary.
Buy Generic Lyrica
April 7, 2012   04:56 AM PDT
 
I am so grateful to read this such a wonderful post. Thank you for discussing this great topic. I really admire the writer for allotting their time for this impressive article. Thank you
GHD Hair Straighteners
April 4, 2012   07:40 PM PDT
 
Thanks for sharing this opinion. Regards for you. Good job! Very helpful information This is a cool blogging platform.
Chloe Bags
March 27, 2012   08:07 PM PDT
 
Thanks for sharing this opinion. Regards for you. Good job! Very helpful information This is a cool blogging platform.
Juicy Couture Handbags
March 21, 2012   01:28 AM PDT
 
what you have said in this article has deeply impressed me and i wish you can write more about this subject.
Coach Bags
March 19, 2012   07:17 PM PDT
 
Surely agree with simply what you said. Your explanation was certainly the simplest to comprehend.
domain names registration indi
February 22, 2012   09:09 PM PST
 
Great! Well, I admire the precious time and effort you put into it, especially into interesting articles you share here! It was very interesting..
Matt Walker
January 8, 2012   11:11 PM PST
 
Great post - it┤s quite interesting.. Thanks for this sharing..
Columbus Web Design
October 19, 2011   04:40 AM PDT
 
Don't kill the messenger they say. Chris Rock is amazing indeed.
Social Media Marketing Service
September 21, 2011   01:30 AM PDT
 
Quite interesting and nice topic chosen for the post. I would collect more information about this topic.
Apcalis
September 13, 2011   03:58 AM PDT
 
I really like the comedy shows. My whole family really enjoy the comedy shows. Thanks for this info.
Buy Generic Viagra Online
August 25, 2011   07:23 AM PDT
 
A great informative blog. Keep posting articles like. You have a great knowledge of the subject...
Corbin
September 21, 2010   06:49 AM PDT
 
I think so this post is very interesting and usefull for all us. We must follow this every time.
Stacey
November 14, 2008   05:59 PM PST
 
Unless the comedian is Jerry Seinfelt. Both times I've seen him lately the crowd yells out his bits and scenes from the TV show in order to get him to "do" them. He seems quite annoyed by it.
gurn blanston
October 23, 2008   06:22 AM PDT
 
haven't seen it yet but want to add a point about the contrast between comedy and music. Not only do many audiences want to hear only familiar songs but they get bent out of shape if it's not performed as on the recording.
katie W jones
October 17, 2008   01:11 PM PDT
 
I saw the Chris Rock special. He is still very funny. I enjoyed the special, but he clearly is not as funny as he was when he was much younger. With that being said, he is much funnier than most comedians.
Mark
October 15, 2008   08:29 PM PDT
 
Thomas - I saw some of the special and agree with your assessment. Kudos to Chris Rock for attempting something fresh, but I found the edits a bit jarring/distracting. He's still a funny bastard.

Leave a Comment:

Name


Homepage (optional)


Comments